Do you think the Fibre Channel over Ethernet (FCoE) protocol will replace Fibre Channel any time soon?
Do you have a question for our experts?
Submit your question directly to our editors at firstname.lastname@example.org
FCoE architecture will not replace Fibre Channel anytime soon, in my opinion. Fibre Channel over Ethernet shipped under 2 million ports in 2012, according to a study I recently read, while Fibre Channel shipped over 4.5 billion. Fibre Channel is familiar and works like a champ. It is a very low-overhead protocol, whereas with FCoE, you are forced to rely on a high-overhead Ethernet packet. Fibre Channel now ships 16 Gbps and the Ethernet counterpart, at least today, is stuck at 10.
Read more about FCoE architecture
FCoE network convergence will start at the edge but move to the rack
End-to-end FCoE for network convergence won't work!
What's more, while they say Ethernet saves on the number of ports, cables, etc., the last time I checked, the power required for the converged adapter was higher than separate Fibre Channel and Ethernet ports. Cables typically carry a 90-day warranty as opposed to a 20-year warranty that you would get with a structured cabling system. Reducing the number of switches required (which is very easy with 10GBASE-T) also reduces the number of required uplink ports.
I'm not saying FCoE architecture will never be used, but that the hype is just that -- hype.
Dig deeper on Storage Networks
Related Q&A from Carrie Higbie
Expert Carrie Higbie explains that top-of-rack switching may mean higher costs due to an oversubscription of ports that you don't need and can't use.continue reading
When trying to remove density in the network, using blade server switches may help solve the problem, as well as offer latency advantages. Expert ...continue reading
Is the rise of 10GBASE-T switches the end of using a copper cabling system in the network? Data Infrastructure expert, Carrie Higbie provides an ...continue reading
Have a question for an expert?
Please add a title for your question
Get answers from a TechTarget expert on whatever's puzzling you.